Xử phúc thẩm vụ “tranh chấp hợp đồng dịch vụ điện”: Giữ nguyên bản án sơ thẩm
(QT) - Chiều ngày 27/8, Tòa án nhân dân tỉnh Quảng Trị đã mở phiên tòa phúc thẩm vụ án dân sự “Tranh chấp hợp đồng dịch vụ điện” giữa nguyên đơn là ông Nguyễn Văn Vinh (SN 1964, trú tại thôn Liêm Công Phường, xã Vĩnh Thành, huyện Vĩnh Linh) và bị đơn là các ông: Trần Văn Vinh, nguyên Chủ nhiệm Hợp tác xã Liêm Công Tây; Lê Văn Hiền (Kế toán HTX); Lê Văn Tường (thợ điện HTX); bên có trách nhiệm liên quan là HTX Liêm Công Tây. Như Báo Quảng Trị đã đưa tin, ngày 14/6/2013, TAND huyện Vĩnh Linh đã ...
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