Xử phúc thẩm vụ “tranh chấp hợp đồng dịch vụ điện”: Giữ nguyên bản án sơ thẩm
(QT) - Chiều ngày 27/8, Tòa án nhân dân tỉnh Quảng Trị đã mở phiên tòa phúc thẩm vụ án dân sự “Tranh chấp hợp đồng dịch vụ điện” giữa nguyên đơn là ông Nguyễn Văn Vinh (SN 1964, trú tại thôn Liêm Công Phường, xã Vĩnh Thành, huyện Vĩnh Linh) và bị đơn là các ông: Trần Văn Vinh, nguyên Chủ nhiệm Hợp tác xã Liêm Công Tây; Lê Văn Hiền (Kế toán HTX); Lê Văn Tường (thợ điện HTX); bên có trách nhiệm liên quan là HTX Liêm Công Tây. Như Báo Quảng Trị đã đưa tin, ngày 14/6/2013, TAND huyện Vĩnh Linh đã ...
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