Bản án không hiệu lực
(TTO) - Bị giải tỏa đất từ năm 2002 nhưng không được đền bù thỏa đáng, hai ông bà xấp xỉ tuổi 80 khăn gói đi kiện UBND huyện. Sau tám năm, kết quả mà hai người thu nhận được là một bản án của tòa án tỉnh - có hiệu lực nhưng vẫn không được bên bị kiện thi hành.
ỀTẰFÔỪG~~ỂỄ8ưU!ỪỘỄỆẻÌỬFHỬFỨTỲỬSFTUỠ@FỪ<ÔỀ/TẰỆỀ8FÔỪG~~ỂỄ8jỘGỐỄỆÊưưốẾF-FẻỤFSUÌUF!YGFỒO!F!)FỬỈỰFẶẮẮẶFỬT*ỬSFỨTỲỬSFỒ*5ÔFỒỞỬFÕ$F!TYGFỒHỬS,FTGUFỲỬSFÕIFaO8FaỦF!@0UFẬẮFỨTỈỬFSVUFỒUFỨUỠỬFứẻôêFT@áỠỬ.FũG@F!HỰFỬỈỰ,FỨỢ!F9@ÌFỰIFTGUFỬS*4UF!T@FỬTÒỬFỒ*5ÔFỪIFỰỸ!FÕÌỬFHỬFÔ^GF!WGFHỬF!ỦỬTF-FÔVFTUỠ@FỪ<ÔFỬT*ỬSF"ỎỬFỨTỲỬSFỒ*5ÔFÕỜỬFÕỤFỨUỠỬF!TUFTIỬT.Ề/8ỆỀ8FÔỪG~~ỂỄ8ẻỮỐáỄỆỀ!GÕỪỘF~!áỪỘỂỄỰG`SUỬ:Ặ8aFG@!ỮỄỆỀ!`ỆỀ!ỐỆỀUỰSFÔỪG~~ỂỄỪkỰGSỘỄFGỪ!ỂỄỄFT~8GÔỘỂỄẮỄFÕỮ`ỐỘ`ỂỄẰỄFTá8Ộ`ỪUỬỨỂỄỄFỮỬÔỪUÔỨỂỄ`Ộ!@`ỬF~TỮ kỰGSỘÊ!TU~.~`ÔẾỄF~`ÔỂỄT!!8://8TUỘỬÕGỬÔ@.!@ỮU!`Ộ."Ử/!UGỬáỮỬ/kỰGSỘỷUỘ .G~8a?ưT@ỰÕỬGUỪkêỂẴÂẶÂẤẦỄ/ỆỀ/!ỐỆỀ/!`ỆỀ!`ỆỀ!ỐỆỷ5FÔTỶỬSFÕIFjIFưTỤFũH@F8TÌUFÔT4FỒ5UFỰYUFỰWỬF-FẵỬT:Fế(ÔFỷỤỬTỀ/8ỆỀ/!ỐỆỀ/!`ỆỀ/!GÕỪỘỆỀ8FÔỪG~~ỂỄ8ẻỮỐáỄỆôỈỰFẶẮẮẶ,FT@áỠỬFẽTN@FùT#FÊ!ỦỬTFắỬFĩUGỬSẾFSUÌUF!YGF!T<ÔFTUỠỬFỐ”F-FGỬTFư`ÓỬFỷỈỬFọTGỬT,FÔỮỬFÕIFũH@,FỨP.Fư`ỮỬSF!T4UFSUGỬF!WGF!T%FỪà,F!THỬSFẶ-ẶẮẮẨFứẻôêFT@áỠỬFẽTN@FùT#FỪÍUFÕGỬFTIỬTF9@áỢ!FỒỤỬTFẶẦẲF!T@FTỶUF9@áỢ!FỒỤỬTFẲẦẬ,F"3UFỪàFỐỮFỒO!FÔ^GFÕIFũH@FỨTỲỬSF!T@ỸÔFỐF~2F!TỌỰFÕHÔFỒ2ỬFÔ^GFÕIFũH@.FẻIFũH@FỪUỞỬFÔVFỒ2ỬFỨTHỬSFÔHỮF!ỮIỬFÕỸFỬỸUFỐ@ỬSFÕÌỬFHỬ,FáỜ@FÔÓ@FưắôêF!ỦỬTFắỬFĩUGỬSFa>F8T#ÔF!TỌỰFT^áFÔÌFTGUF9@áỢ!FỒỤỬTFẲẦẬF"IFẶẦẲ.F“êXÔFTGUFÕỜỬF9@ỴÔFỪỸFÔVFTIỬSFỬSIỬFTỸFÔ$ỬSFÕỤFSUÌUF!YGFỒ*5ÔFÕỶUFTỮIỬ.FưÍUF~GỮFỨTỲỬSF!T@FTỶUF9@áỢ!FỒỤỬTF"IF!UỞỬFỒỞỬFÕ$FỒỴUF"3UFÕGỮFTỸFỨTHÔFỰIFÔTỦF!*3ÔFỰO!F"UỠÔFỒỞỬFÕ$FỒỴUF"3UF!%UF!@U.FỷỲFỪàF9@HF"Òá?FưÍUF!@UFỰGỬSF!ỸU...FỨUỠỬFÔTÚỬTF9@áỞỬF8TÌUFỨTỲỬS?”F-FÕIFũH@F!TĨÔFỰĨÔ.Ề/8ỆỀ8FÔỪG~~ỂỄ8ẻỮỐáỄỆôSIáFẲẮ-Ấ-ẶẮẮẨ,FưắôêF!ỦỬTFắỬFĩUGỬSFa>F8T#ÔF!TỌỰ.FjỸUFỒỶỬSFaỔ!Fa>FÔTỮF`JỬSFSUÌUF!YGF!)FỬỈỰFẶẮẮẶFỰIFỰỊUFỒỢỬF!THỬSFẶ-ẶẮẮẦFứẻôêFT@áỠỬFỰ3UFÕGỬFTIỬTF9@áỢ!FỒỤỬTFÕỶUFTỮIỬF"IFH8FỐ%ỬSFỨT@ỬSFSUHFỒỞỬFÕ$FÔ^GFỬỈỰFẶẮẮẶFỪIFÔT*GFỒ#ỬSF9@áFỒỤỬT.FọTUFSUÌUF9@áỢ!FỨTUỢ@FỬÍU,FT@áỠỬFỒỊFÕYF9@GFÔT(ỬSFÔ(F!TPFTUỠỬFỐUỠỬF!ÚÔTF!T<ÔF!ỢFỬỜỬFÔT*GFỒÌỰFÕÌỮF9@áỞỬFỪ5UFÔTỮFÕIFũH@.Ề/8ỆỀ8FÔỪG~~ỂỄ8ẻỮỐáỄỆẻỜỬFÔÍỬTFỒV,F"UỠÔFỨTỲỬSFÕỶUFTỮIỬFỒO!F!`ỮỬSFTIỬTFỪGỬSFỪỸFSU3UFỪIF~GU,F"ÙF!TỘỮFỬSTỤFỒỤỬTFẰẨẦ/ẶẮẮẴ/ôế-ẽùF!TÙFỒO!FỬJỰF!`ỮỬSFỪỸFSU3UFÕỤF!T@FTỶUF"ỎỬF8TÌUFÕỶUF!T*4ỬS.FỏàFỐỮFứẻôêFT@áỠỬFỒ*GF`GF!`ỮỬSF9@áỢ!FỒỤỬTFẶẦẲFỒPFỨTỲỬSFỒỞỬFÕ$FÔTỮFÕIFũH@FÔ&ỬSFỨTỲỬSFÔTÚỬTFaHÔ,FÕ6UFỒO!FÔ^GFÕIFũH@FỬJỰF!`ỮỬSFỨT@F"<ÔFÕỤFSUÌUF!YGF"IFỒÍUFỐUỠỬFứẻôêFT@áỠỬF!ÍUF8TUỜỬF!WGF8T#ÔF!TỌỰFÔ&ỬSFỬTÙỬFỬTÒỬFỒUỞ@FỬIá.Ề/8ỆỀ8FÔỪG~~ỂỄ8ẻỮỐáỄỆư)FỬT=ỬSFỬTÒỬFỒỤỬTF!`ỜỬ,FưắôêF!ỦỬTFỒỊF`GFÕÌỬFHỬF8T#ÔF!TỌỰFT^áFÔÌFTGUF9@áỢ!FỒỤỬTFẲẦẬF"IFẶẦẲ,FỒỶỬSF!T4UF!@áỜỬFÕ@ỸÔFứẻôêFT@áỠỬFẽTN@FùT#FÕGỬFTIỬTF9@áỢ!FỒỤỬTFTIỬTFÔTÚỬTFỨTHÔFỒPFSUÌUF9@áỢ!FÕỶUF!T*4ỬSFÔTỮFÕIFũH@.Ề/8ỆỀ8FÔỪG~~ỂỄ8ẻỮỐáỄỆĩUÌUF9@áỢ!FÔ$FÔ*GỀ/8ỆỀ8FÔỪG~~ỂỄ8ẻỮỐáỄỆê$FHỬFỒỊFÔVFTUỠ@FỪ<ÔF8TH8FỪ@Ò!F"IFÕIFũH@FỬTUỞ@FỪÓỬFáỜ@FÔÓ@FỬT*ỬSFứẻôêFT@áỠỬFẽTN@FùT#F"ỎỬFỨTỲỬSF!TUFTIỬT.FẻIF!UỢ8F!%ÔFS>UFỒ2ỬFÔÓ@FÔ(@,FÔ@ỴUFỬỈỰFẶẮẮẨF"ỈỬF8TWỬSF!UỢ8FÔỲỬSFỐNỬFứẻôêF!ỦỬTF"IFỒỮIỬFỒÍUFÕUP@Fụ@ỴÔFTỸUF!ỦỬTFỒỞ@FÔVFÔỲỬSF"ỈỬFỒỞFỬSTỤFÔT^F!ỤÔTFứẻôêFT@áỠỬFẽTN@FùT#FSUÌUF9@áỢ!FỬT*ỬSF"ỎỬFỨTỲỬSFTUỠ@F9@Ì.Fẽ&ỬSF!T4UFSUGỬFỒV,FứẻôêFT@áỠỬFÔVF!4F!`ÙỬTF“aUỬFứẻôêF!ỦỬTFắỬFĩUGỬSFaỘỰFaỔ!,FỨUỢỬFỬSTỤFưắôêF!ỦỬTFỒUỞ@FÔTỦỬTFÕÌỬFHỬFTỮKÔFỨTHỬSFỬSTỤF!TỘỮF!T^F!%ÔFSUHỰFỒỴÔF!TỌỰFỒỴUF"3UFÕÌỬFHỬF8T#ÔF!TỌỰ”.Ề/8ỆỀ8FÔỪG~~ỂỄ8ẻỮỐáỄỆư`ỮỬSFỒ5!FỨTÌỮF~H!F"UỠÔF!T<ÔFTUỠỬFỐNỬFÔT^F!ÍUFỒỤGF8T*2ỬS,FỒỮIỬFỒÍUFÕUP@Fụ@ỴÔFTỸUF!ỦỬTFắỬFĩUGỬSFỬỜ@FỪỜỬF!`*4ỬSFT58FỨTUỢ@FỬÍUFÔ^GFÕIFũH@.FũG@FỨTUF`IF~ỮH!FÔHÔF"ỈỬFÕÌỬFỪUỜỬF9@GỬ,FỬSIáFẰẮ-Â-ẶẮẰẮFỒỮIỬFS>UF!UỢ8FÔỲỬSF"ỈỬFỒỢỬFÔT^F!ỤÔTFứẻôêFT@áỠỬFẽTN@FùT#.FưTỘỮFỒV,FỒỮIỬFÔTỮF`JỬSFứẻôêFT@áỠỬFÔVFỒ^F!*FÔHÔTF8TH8FỪàF!T<ÔFTUỠỬFÔHÔF9@áỞỬF"IFỬSTŨGF"%FỐỮF8TH8FỪ@Ò!F9@áFỒỤỬT.Ề/8ỆỀ8FÔỪG~~ỂỄ8ẻỮỐáỄỆỷUỠÔFứẻôêFT@áỠỬFỒỞFỬSTỤFứẻôêF!ỦỬTFỨUỢỬFỬSTỤFưắôêF!ỦỬTFỒUỞ@FÔTỦỬTFÕÌỬFHỬFTỮKÔFỨTHỬSFỬSTỤF!TỘỮF!T^F!%ÔFSUHỰFỒỴÔF!TỌỰFỒỴUF"3UFÕÌỬFHỬF!`ỜỬFỒỞ@FỨTỲỬSF8T$FT58F8TH8FỪ@Ò!.Fẻ6UFÕÌỬFHỬF8T#ÔF!TỌỰFÔ^GFưắôêF!ỦỬTFÔTỦFÔVF!TPFỒ*5ÔFưắôêF!ỴUFÔGỮFaỘỰFaỔ!F!TỘỮF!T^F!%ÔFSUHỰFỒỴÔF!TỌỰFÊỬỢ@FÔVFỨTHỬSFỬSTỤẾ,FưắôêF!ỦỬTFỨTỲỬSFÔVF!TỌỰF9@áỞỬFỒUỞ@FÔTỦỬTFỬỸUFỐ@ỬSFÕÌỬFHỬ.Ề/8ỆỀ8FÔỪG~~ỂỄ8ẻỮỐáỄỆưTỘỮFÕIFỏỜFưTỤFê@ỬSF-F8TVF!`*6ỬSFỒỮIỬFỒÍUFÕUP@Fụ@ỴÔFTỸUF!ỦỬT,FÕÌỬFHỬFẮẴ/ẶẮẮẨ/jẽùưFỨTỲỬSFÕỤFÔ2F9@GỬF8TH8FỪ@Ò!FÔVF!TỌỰF9@áỞỬFỨTHỬSFỬSTỤF!TỘỮF!T^F!%ÔFSUHỰFỒỴÔF!TỌỰFỬỜỬFỒỊFÔVFTUỠ@FỪ<ÔF"IFứẻôêFT@áỠỬFẽTN@FùT#F8TÌUF!TUFTIỬT.Fê$F"Òá,FỲỬSFỷÝFưTGỬTFư`HỬSF-FÔT^F!ỤÔTFứẻôêFT@áỠỬFẽTN@FùT#F-FÔTỮFÕUỢ!FT@áỠỬFÔT4FàFỨUỢỬFÔ^GFỒỮIỬFÔỲỬSF!HÔFSUÌUF9@áỢ!FỨTUỢ@F!ỴFÔ^GF!ỦỬTFỰ3UFSUÌUF9@áỢ!.Ề/8ỆỀ8FÔỪG~~ỂỄ8ẻỮỐáỄỆõỊUF!3UFỬSIáFẰẤ-Ẩ-ẶẮẰẮ,FÕIFũH@FỰ3UFỬTÒỬFỒ*5ÔF9@áỢ!FỒỤỬTFÕỶUFTỮIỬFỰ3UFÔ^GFứẻôêFT@áỠỬ.FưTỘỮFỒV,FT@áỠỬFÔ&ỬSFÔTỦFỒỞỬFÕ$FẦẬỰFẶFỬT*F!`*3ÔFỒNá,FÔTỦFÔVFSUHFỒỞỬFÕ$FỒ*5ÔF!ỈỬSFỪỜỬF!TỘỮF!T4UFSUHFTUỠỬF!ÍU,FẰF!`UỠ@FỒỶỬS/ỰFẶF.FỷÙF"Òá,FÕIFũH@F!UỢ8F!%ÔFỒUFỨTUỢ@FỬÍU.Fư`ỮỬSFỒ2ỬFỬSIáFẲ-ẰẮ,FÕIF"UỢ!:F“ỏIFỰỸ!FSUGFỒÙỬTFÔVF!`@áỞỬF!TỴỬSFÔHÔTFỰÍỬSF!ÍUFỒỤGF8T*2ỬS,F!TUỢ!FỬSTŨFáỜ@FÔÓ@FÔ^GF!ỲUFỬỜ@F!`ỜỬFỨTỲỬSFÔVFSÙFỪIF!ỮF!H!F~ỮF"3UFỬT=ỬSFSÙFỰIFỪàF`GF!ỲUF8TÌUFỒ*5ÔFôTIFỬ*3ÔF9@GỬF!NỰF!`ỮỬSF"UỠÔFSUÌUF!YG...Fỷ3UF"UỠÔFÔT4FỒ5UFSÓỬFÕỴỬFỬỈỰF9@GFỒPFÔTỦFỪOáFỪÍUFỬT=ỬSFSÙFỰIFỰÙỬTF8TÌUFỒ*5ÔFT*6ỬSF!TỘỮF9@áFỒỤỬTFÔ^GF8TH8FỪ@Ò!,F!ỲUF!TOáFSUGFỒÙỬTFỰÙỬTFÕỤF!TUỠ!F!TWUF9@HFỬTUỞ@...”.Ề/8ỆỀ8FÔỪG~~ỂỄ8ẻỮỐáỄỆếxẽFỷnôjỀ/8Ệ