Án lệ và việc áp dụng án lệ
(NDĐT) - Cùng bị truy tố về tội trộm cắp xe máy, cùng có chung những tình tiết phạm tội cơ bản giống nhau, nhưng một bị cáo bị TAND huyện A tuyên án ba năm tù, còn một bị cáo khác bị TAND huyện B tuyên phạt bốn năm tù. Đây là thực tế vẫn diễn ra nhiều năm qua, do khung hình phạt cho tội danh này được quy định từ hai năm đến bảy năm tù.
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