Cần khách quan hơn khi nói về thưởng Tết của giáo viên
Cập nhật: 05:29 29/01/2010 GMT+7
(GD&TĐ) - Chúng tôi là người luôn trăn trở về mức lương của nhà giáo hiện nay, và chế độ đãi ngộ thấp dành cho đội ngũ “kĩ sư tâm hồn”. Tuy nhiên, khi đọc bài “Hy vọng năm mới, giáo viên sống được bằng lương” của Thu Thủy trên Diễn đàn Dân trí ngày 13/1/10, chúng tôi vẫn còn một số băn khoăn, xin được trao đổi thêm.
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