GMT+7
Cần hiểu đúng, trúng và đưa chức năng “phản biện” vào đời sống xã hội
(QT) - Phản biện, theo từ điển tiếng Việt của Viện Ngôn ngữ (xuất bản năm 1998) đưa ra khái niệm với nội dung hạn hẹp chỉ “việc đánh gia một công trình khoa học khi được đưa ra bảo vệ để lấy học vị”. Song lịch sử nhân loại minh chứng rằng không có “phản biện” sẽ không có sự phát triển. Trong khoa học thì điều đó quá rõ, bởi lẽ khoa học là “một chuổi sai lầm được sữa chữa” mà sữa chữa được là nhờ có phản biện, tức là có sự tranh luận, phê phán cái sai, thừa nhận cái đúng đắn. Đặc biệt, khi tiếp ...
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